Buying a new vs. used piano: a decision guide – Musik-Ebert Gmbh

Anyone looking to buy a piano faces a basic question early on: new or used? Both routes have good arguments, and the right answer depends on your budget, your expectations, and how long the instrument is meant to stay with you.

This guide weighs the pros and cons objectively, shows what really matters when buying used, and ends with a direct comparison. That way you can decide whether a new or a used piano suits you better.

New piano

Current build, full warranty, free choice of model and finish.

Ideal for: Ideal if you want a specific model, a particular colour, or a silent system and value a warranty.

See all Klaviere - Neu →

Used piano

More instrument for your budget, a played-in tone, stable value with good brands.

Ideal for: Ideal if your budget is limited or you deliberately want a higher-quality branded instrument for the price of a new entry-level piano.

See all Klaviere - Gebraucht →

01What speaks for a new piano

A new piano arrives in its current build: the latest action generation, fresh strings and felts, a soundboard with no signs of ageing. There is no history you have to assess.

On top of that come the full warranty and free choice. You decide on the model, the size, the finish (polished black, white, wood) and added technology such as a silent system, which lets you also play the acoustic piano through headphones. With a new instrument you get exactly the combination you want.

In the mid price range, models like the Yamaha B10 Klavier schwarz poliert or the Kawai K-200 Klavier schwarz poliert are typical entry points into buying new. You will find the full range in the category Klaviere - Neu.

Yamaha B20 Klavier schwarz poliert - Musik-Ebert Gmbh

Yamaha B10 Klavier schwarz poliert

View product →

Kawai K-200 Klavier schwarz poliert

View product →

Yamaha B20 Klavier schwarz poliert

View product →

02What speaks for a used piano

A piano is not a consumable: a well-built instrument lasts for decades. That is exactly what makes buying used attractive. For the budget of a new entry-level piano, you can often get a higher-quality branded instrument second-hand.

Good brands are also stable in value. A played-in piano has found its tone over the years, and wood that has been under tension for a long time has settled. With renowned makers, the value is preserved over a long period.

The spectrum ranges from well-maintained Yamaha pianos to German makes such as Schimmel or Wilhelm Steinberg, and includes instruments with a retrofitted silent system. Every used piano in our shop has been inspected, and the selection changes continually: you will find the current range in the category Klaviere - Gebraucht.

03What to look for when buying used

A used piano deserves a few more careful looks than a new one. Four points are decisive:

Age and provenance. The year of manufacture and previous ownership give clues about the condition. Branded instruments with traceable provenance are the safer choice than an anonymous bargain.

Tuning stability. A healthy piano holds its tuning for months. If it drops off sharply after a short time, that can point to a tired pin block.

Action and key travel. All keys should respond evenly and without rattling, and every note should be audible. An uneven or stiff touch indicates wear in the action.

Soundboard and strings. Cracks in the soundboard, heavily rusted strings, or corrosion on the tuning pins are more serious than superficial signs of use on the case.

With these criteria, a well-maintained branded instrument can be clearly told apart from a problem case.

04New or used in a direct comparison

The following overview summarises the main differences. It shows that neither route is fundamentally better; what matters are your priorities.

New vs. used piano at a glance
Criterion	New piano	Used piano
Value for money	fixed new price	often more instrument for your budget
Warranty	full manufacturer warranty	depending on the seller, usually shorter
Choice	model, colour, technology freely selectable	depends on available stock
Tone	still needs playing in	already played in
Risk	predictable	condition must be assessed
Value over time	initial markdown from new price	stable with good brands

New or used is not a question of right or wrong. Anyone who values a warranty, free choice and the current build will do well with a new piano. Anyone who wants as much instrument as possible for their budget and pays attention to condition and brand will often find a better deal used. Both routes lead to an instrument you can enjoy for a long time.

Frequently asked questions

Is a used piano a good alternative to a new one?

Yes. A well-built piano lasts for decades, and for the budget of a new entry-level piano you can often get a higher-quality branded instrument used. The prerequisite is that condition and provenance are right.

How old can a used piano be?

There is no fixed maximum age. What matters is the condition, not the year of manufacture: a well-maintained instrument from 30 years ago can be better than a neglected one from ten years ago. More important than the number are tuning stability, the action and the soundboard.

What should I check first when buying used?

The tuning stability, an even key travel without rattling, a crack-free soundboard, and a traceable provenance of the instrument. Branded instruments with a known history are the safer choice.

Does a new piano lose a lot of value?

As with most purchases, there is an initial markdown compared with the new price. With renowned brands the value then stabilises and is preserved over many years, which supports the used market for those brands.

Is a new piano with a silent system worth it?

If you also want to play late in the evening or in thin-walled flats, yes. A silent system makes the acoustic piano quietly playable through headphones, without replacing the acoustic tone. Such equipment can be specifically selected when buying new.